UBC October 2026 - The AI Equalizer

Let's resume yesterday's discussion.

A while ago, I was talking to a friend whose brother teaches apprentices at a vocational school. He teaches future retail employees, or Detailhandelsangestellte, and naturally, the subject of this year's final exams came up.

What she told me left me scratching my head.

Switzerland is adapting vocational education to the modern workplace, including teaching apprentices how to use AI. Fair enough. AI is going to be part of working life, so young people need to know how to use it, and how to judge whether what it produces actually makes sense.

But apparently, AI was also allowed to assist during the final exams.

Photo Credit:  Gera Cejas on Pexels


My friend's brother watched students who had shown little engagement or competence during their training suddenly produce beautifully structured answers. AI fixed their grammar, improved their wording and supplied ideas.

The problem?

The students who actually thought through their answers themselves needed more time.

And that is where I have a problem.

Surely there is a difference between knowing how to use a tool and knowing what you are doing in the first place.

Consider something as simple as working at a food counter.

You put a customer's lunchbox on the scale. The scale gives you the total weight. You subtract the weight of the empty container — the Tara — and charge for the food.

That's it.

No complicated software. No advanced mathematics. No AI.

And yet, according to what my friend's brother hears from the retail world, there are apprentices who have been shown this repeatedly and still don't understand what they are supposed to do.

They stand there looking at the scale as if it has just presented them with a philosophical dilemma.

And that's more worrying to me than a polished exam answer.

Because when you're standing behind a food counter and the lunch queue is growing, you can't ask AI what to do next. You need to understand the problem and solve it.

AI can help you think. It cannot replace having something to think with.

So perhaps the question isn't whether students should be allowed to use AI. Of course they should learn to use it.

The question is what they need to know before they use it.

Math. Language. Concentration. Reading a question properly. Thinking things through. Solving a problem without immediately reaching for a device.

And if AI is allowed in an exam, perhaps students should also have to explain their own answers afterwards.

Because if someone can write the perfect AI prompt but can't work out the weight of the food in a lunchbox, I'm not sure we've actually made progress.

We've just made the button-pushing more sophisticated.

Photo Credit: Mart Production on Pexels


Coming up tomorrow: the other side of the problem.

We're teaching young people how to use AI in the workplace and debating how much of their work AI should be allowed to do for them.

Meanwhile, apparently some of them are struggling with something considerably more basic:

Dealing with an actual customer.

Tomorrow's post takes us to Bershka, where I discovered that asking for a pair of baggy jeans can apparently be a surprisingly demanding assignment.

Spoiler: there was no AI involved.

Comments

  1. People can do whatever they want with AI, be it good or bad. Here's my perspective about AI: Does it help advance knowledge? Yes. Is it good for the environment? No. We can be subjective or objective about it. The bottom line is, AI is here to stay, and people just need to be sober and watchful using this technology.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It’s pretty scary isn’t it? Our children have so much intelligence and yet they are growing up in a world where you don’t need to tap into your own, you can tap into AI. Problem solving has become a lost skill.
    I agree, they need to learn to use it as another tool in the tool box. But it can’t replace the human brain!

    ReplyDelete
  3. You raise such an important question about the difference between knowing how to use AI and actually understanding what you’re doing. I’m taking a digital marketing course right now, and this is something I’ve been thinking about, too. AI can be a wonderful resource, but I believe we still need to develop our own critical thinking and problem-solving skills. I especially like your suggestion that students should be able to explain their answers. That would tell us so much more about what they’ve actually learned!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm not a bit fan of AI especially in school exams. As for figuring about the scale, sure they can find it from AI but I think if they had actually learned it the "old fashion way" they would retain the steps. Going through AI you don't have to remember.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Seems like 'they' want to dummy up all of us. Perhaps we are not needed and we'll be replaced by robots soon.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Thank you for your comment. It will be visible as soon as I had a chance to verify that you are not an anonymous user and/or a spammer.